Phytate: impact on environment and human nutrition. A challenge for molecular breeding*
Lisbeth Bohn, Anne S. Meyer, and Søren K. Rasmussen
1. Tiivistelmä,Abstract
IP6, fytiini, käsittää 80 % siitä fosforista, mitä siemenissä on ja vastaa siementen painosta 1,5 prosenttia.
Phytic acid (PA) is the primary storage compound of phosphorus in seeds accounting for up to 80% of the total seed phosphorus and contributing as much as 1.5% to the seed dry weight. The negatively charged phosphate in PA strongly binds to metallic cations of Ca, Fe, K, Mg, Mn and Zn making them insoluble and thus unavailable as nutritional factors. Phytate mainly accumulates in protein storage vacuoles as globoids, predominantly located in the aleurone layer (wheat, barley and rice) or in the embryo (maize). During germination, phytate is hydrolysed by endogenous phytase(s) and other phosphatases to release phosphate, inositol and micronutrients to support the emerging seedling. PA and its derivatives are also implicated in RNA export, DNA repair, signalling, endocytosis and cell vesicular trafficking. Our recent studies on purification of phytate globoids, their mineral composition and dephytinization by wheat phytase will be discussed. Biochemical data for purified and characterized phytases isolated from more than 23 plant species are presented, the dephosphorylation pathways of phytic acid by different classes of phytases are compared, and the application of phytase in food and feed is discussed.
Phytic acid (PA) is the primary storage compound of phosphorus in seeds accounting for up to 80% of the total seed phosphorus and contributing as much as 1.5% to the seed dry weight. The negatively charged phosphate in PA strongly binds to metallic cations of Ca, Fe, K, Mg, Mn and Zn making them insoluble and thus unavailable as nutritional factors. Phytate mainly accumulates in protein storage vacuoles as globoids, predominantly located in the aleurone layer (wheat, barley and rice) or in the embryo (maize). During germination, phytate is hydrolysed by endogenous phytase(s) and other phosphatases to release phosphate, inositol and micronutrients to support the emerging seedling. PA and its derivatives are also implicated in RNA export, DNA repair, signalling, endocytosis and cell vesicular trafficking. Our recent studies on purification of phytate globoids, their mineral composition and dephytinization by wheat phytase will be discussed. Biochemical data for purified and characterized phytases isolated from more than 23 plant species are presented, the dephosphorylation pathways of phytic acid by different classes of phytases are compared, and the application of phytase in food and feed is discussed.
Keywords: Phytase, Phytic acid, Iron bioavailability, Antinutritional factor, Purple acid phosphatase, Cereal
2. INTRODUCTION
A
complete understanding of the biosynthesis of phytic acid (PA) in
plants based on a single model species cannot be achieved and
comparative studies are needed. Even if the same core set of inositol
phosphate kinases (Ipks) should exist in the plant kingdom, the
coordination of biosynthesis, translocation, site of accumulation and
storage vary among species. This is exemplified by the fact that in
wheat, barley and rice the majority of phytate accumulates in the
aleurone cells and only minor amounts in the embryo. The distribution of
phytate is just opposite in the maize seeds, which means that within
relatively closely related grasses different control points exist. PA
biosynthesis initiates shortly after flowering and it accumulates during
development until seed maturation and desiccation. During this period
of plant development changes in growth conditions occurs: rain, drought,
high temperature and pathogens. Individual inositolphosphate kinases
accept a broad range of substrates and it is also evident that rice and
barley Ipks have phosphatase and isomerase activity. These multiple
activities provide degrees of freedom for controlling and fine tuning
the PA biosynthesis and accumulation, but it also poses a challenge for
molecular breeding strategies, because mutations in one kinase gene can
be compensated for by other activities.
During
the past years, attention has been focused on PA as an antinutritional
factor in the diet of humans because of their inability to utilize
phytate. The low bioavailability of the minerals bound in the PA can
lead to deficiencies in human populations where staples like wheat, rice
and maize are the major or the only source of nutrition. In the case of
livestock production, excretion of PA can lead to accumulation of P in
soil and water, and subsequently to eutrophication of fresh water
streams and near coastal seawaters. Low-PA mutant seeds can potentially
reduce these problems. Many low PA mutants have been produced in most of
the important crop. However, many examples indicate that random
mutations seem to affect PA biosynthesis throughout the plant life cycle
and not just in the seeds. At present, little is known about the impact
of these mutations on agronomical important quality parameters such as
stress response or disease susceptibility of plants. Therefore methods
acting exclusively on the biosynthesis of PA are needed to produce
sustainable low PA seeds.
3. NUTRITIONAL ASPECTS
3.1. Micronutrient malnutrition and distribution
The main micronutrient deficiencies in the world involve Fe, Zn and Vitamin A (WHO, 2002).
The three factors are closely related and, in the correct combination,
the uptake of one will enhance the uptake of another, and especially
fats or proteins from meat will enhance uptake of all of them (Gibson et
al., 2006; Lonnerdal, 2000; Storcksdieck et al., 2007).
In developing countries plant foods are the major staples of the diet.
Particularly in diets based on unrefined cereals or legumes the
bioavailability of several micronutrients, such as Ca, Fe, Zn, I and
some vitamins can be quite low, causing metabolic disorders related to
these nutritional factors. Consequently, improving the nutritional value
of this type of foods would improve the nutritional status of the
entire population. The transgenic rice line “Golden Rice” is a good
example of how the effect of extra β-carotene can decrease Vitamin A
deficiency (Zimmermann and Hurrell, 2002). Unfortunately, similar work has not yet been pursued in wheat, the staple cereal of developed countries.
The
mineral bioavailability of wheat depends on the cultivar, environment
and harvest year. Positive correlations between Zn and Fe have been
found in both spring and winter wheat, but these elements were
negatively correlated with Mn and P. Furthermore, genotype seems to
influence Fe concentrations (Morgounov et al., 2007),
while its content is positively correlated with grain size rather than
phytate content, suggesting that ferritin deposits are involved in
storage of Fe (Grusak et al., 1999). Zn uptake depends more on geographical location (Morgounov et al., 2007)
but positive associations between phytate and zinc have been reported
as well as evidence that the position on the spike also influences the
composition of the minerals in grain (Liu et al., 2006).
Mineral, phosphorous and phytate content is much higher in the bran than in the whole grain (Guttieri et al., 2003; Iskander and Morad, 1986; Steiner et al., 2007),
but also within the bran fractions differences occur. Pearling of wheat
has shown that the outer 0~4% layer of wheat has the highest Zn
content, whereas the next outer 4%~8% layer has the highest phytase
activity, phytate and iron contents. However, the differences are small
in the outer 0~12% layer, proving that storage of all of these compounds
takes place in the bran (Liu Z.H. et al., 2007).
Factors
involved in micronutrient malnutrition outside the grain are, for
example, the chemical form of the nutrient in the food matrix,
interactions with other compounds or treatment of the food prior to
ingestion. Iron bioavailability will be used to exemplify it.
3.2. Iron uptake and bioavailability
There
are two types of iron in the human diet; both of them are mostly
absorbed in the proximal part of the duodenum. Heme iron origins from
meat products and consists of iron complexed with the porphyrin ring
from either haemoglobin or myoglobin. It only accounts for approximately
10%~20% of dietary iron, but for up to 50% of the iron actually
entering the body (Carpenter and Mahoney, 1992). Specific receptors for heme iron on the microvilli of the enterocytes have been identified (Krishnamurthy et al., 2007; Worthington et al., 2001) and the iron is easily absorbed and split from the complex by heme oxygenase inside the cell (Raffin et al., 1974).
The
second type of iron is non-heme iron from plants. Unlike heme-iron, its
uptake depends on the composition of the meal and other factors in the
degradation pathway. Absorption by the enterocytes involves reduction
from ferric (Fe3+) to ferrous (Fe2+) iron (Mckie et al., 2001) before co-transport with a proton across the membrane by divalent metal transporter 1 (DMT1) (Andrews, 1999; Gunshin et al., 1997).
Iron is then released into the bloodstream by ferrous ion transporter
(FPN) and absorbed by cells through the “transferrin cycle”:
iron-transferrin is bound by transferrin receptors and internalised by
endocytosis. Proton pumps create an acidic environment inside the
endosome and iron is released from the transferrin. Iron is now
available to the cell either for biologically active compounds or for
storage, and the transferrin and transferrin receptors are recycled back
to the membrane and the cycle can be repeated (Benito and Miller, 1998).
Beside
the dietary factors described in the next section, a very important
factor, the constitution of the body, also regulates iron absorption.
Humans have no physiologically regulated pathway for iron excretion
(Andrews and Schmidt, 2007) but have the primary physiological factors involved in non-heme iron absorption, which are summarised in Table Table11.
3.3. Dietary factors involved in iron absorption
As
previously mentioned, absorption of non-heme iron depends on its
surroundings. Most of it is found as ferric iron, which precipitates as
iron hydroxide at pH3 if it is not kept in solution by chelators
such as ascorbic acid, peptides or certain sugars and amino acids. In
the following, the effects and mechanisms of some of the most
influential factors on iron bioavailability will be described.
Vitamins:
Ascorbic acid (the active form of Vitamin C) keeps iron available for
absorption through several mechanisms. First, it promotes acidic
conditions in the stomach and intestines, thereby providing optimal
conditions for iron absorption; second, it chelates ferric iron and
maintains it in a stable and soluble complex, even at higher pH. Finally
it reduces ferric iron to its ferrous form, thereby preventing it from
precipitating as ferric hydroxide (Teucher et al., 2004).
Vitamin A or β-carotene also enhances iron absorption through formation
of soluble iron complexes and to a certain extent it can reverse the
effect of several inhibitors such as phytates and polyphenols (Layrisse
et al., 2000).
Meat
is an important enhancer of the bioavailability of non-heme iron. The
“meat factor” is still largely unexplored, but recent findings suggest
that it is due to peptides of myosin, generated by pepsin degradation in
the gut, which binds and keeps iron in solution (Storcksdieck et al., 2007).
Other suggestions to explain the “meat factor” involve sulphydryl
groups of e.g., cysteine, to reduce ferric iron to ferrous iron
(Mulvihill and Morrissey, 1998), and the induction of gastric juice production by proteins (Carpenter and Mahoney, 1992).
Weaker
chelators, such as EDTA, organic acids or amino acids also contribute
to iron solubility and these iron salts (and also ferrous sulphate) are
some of the most commonly used iron fortificants (Hertrampf and
Olivares, 2004; Hurrell et al., 2004; Salovaara et al., 2003b).
Contradictory
to this, iron uptake is inhibited by strong chelators such as PA and
some polyphenols that have a chatechol group in their structure, able to
form very stable chelates (Brune et al., 1989; Tuntawiroon et al., 1991).
In this group of substances, tannic acid is a particularly strong
inhibitor of iron absorption; in vitro experiments have shown that a
molar ratio of 1:10 of tannic acid:iron results in 92% inhibition of
iron absorption; in comparison, to reach the same result a molar ratio
of 10:1 of phytic acid:iron is required (Glahn et al., 2002). However, the type of iron involved in these experiments is an important factor, as FeSO4 has higher solubility than FeCl3 in complexes with PA (Engle-Stone et al., 2005).
Ascorbic acid and meat can to some extent reverse the inhibition of
iron absorption by PA, but not tannic acid. Furthermore, the combination
of tannic acid and fish is even able to decrease iron solubility
further.
Other divalent cations, such as Ca2+ (Hallberg et al., 1992; Perales et al., 2006), Zn2+ (Camara et al., 2007), Co2+ and Mn2+ (Yeung et al., 2005)
competitively inhibit iron absorption, probably because they use the
same transporters (the DMT1) to enter the enterocytes, or because they
co-precipitate with iron in phytic acid salts. The mode of Ca2+-inhibition is still being debated (Perales et al., 2006; Roughead et al., 2005), as Ca2+
seems to have larger impact on heme iron absorption than on non-heme
iron absorption, which could be due to mucosal uptake inhibition.
The
interactions between inhibitors and enhancers decide the final
absorption level of the element in the gut. The sums of the effects are,
in general terms, predictable, and several algorithms to predict the
percentage of non-heme iron absorption from food are available in
literature (Conway et al., 2007).
Despite
these cofactors involved in iron uptake, the main inhibitor of Fe
absorption is phytic acid, and its chemical properties and functions
will be described in the following section.
4. CHEMISTRY OF PHYTIC ACID
4.1. Myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5,6) hexakisphosphate
Inositol
phosphates consist of an inositol ring and at least one phosphate
group. Breaking the name into its separate parts describes the exact
structure and appearance: the prefix “myo” refers to the
conformation of the hydroxyl groups on the inositol ring. The nine
possible configurations of the inositol ring have been annotated in a
number of ways, but the adopted nomenclature is according to the set of
rules suggested by Posternak (1965).
The conformation myo-inositol thus has one plane of symmetry, going directly from the most left to the most right atom (Fig.(Fig.1).1).
The D/L-prefixes specify the numbering direction of carbons in the
inositol ring, where the D annotates counterclockwise and L clockwise
counting, respectively. In general chemistry, numbering of the atoms
should always follow the lowest possible route. Confusions regarding myo-inositols
and enzymes related to them have led the International Union of Pure
and Applied Chemistry and the International Union of Biochemistry
(IUPAC-IUB, 1989) to recommend that the atoms in the myo-inositol
ring should always be numbered according to the D configuration. The
numbering should be initiated at the atom that is esterified in inositol
phospholipids according to Agranoff (1978), using Agranoff’s turtle as a reminder. The four limbs and tail of the turtle are coplanar and represent the five equatorial
hydroxyl groups. The turtle’s head is erect and represents the axial
hydroxyl group. Looking down at the turtle from above, the numbering of
the turtle will begin at the right paw and continue past the head to the
other limbs, thus numbering the inositol in the counterclockwise (D)
direction (Shears, 2004). This way, the plane of symmetry in the “myo”
conformation will always go through C2 and C5, and the L (clockwise)
configuration will start at the turtle’s left paw and the D
configuration will start at the turtle’s right paw.
The
nomenclature of the nine stereoisomers of inositol (Haworth
projections). Seven have a mirror axis in the molecule and numbering of
the carbon atoms can be performed either counterclockwise (D) or
clockwise (L). Only the chiro form has specific D ...
The
consequence is a simplification of the naming of the enzymes related to
the inositol phosphates: any phytase does not automatically produce
D/L-myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5) pentakisphosphate,
thereby obeying the rules of numbering according to the lowest possible
route. The phytase more specifically is named according to the D-myo-inositol pentakisphosphate
that indicates initiation point of hydrolysis. According to this set of
rules, a 3-phytase will initiate dephosphorylation at the C3 atom and
have D-myo-inositol (1,2,4,5,6) pentakisphosphate as
the product. As the enzyme hydrolyses additional phosphate groups from
the inositol ring, the numbering of the groups will remain the same
regardless of which phosphate is hydrolysed and the configurational
counting will not change between the intermediates. Confusions
surrounding the enzymes and their products are however not yet entirely
resolved. The same enzyme some authors annotate as a 4-phytase, others
refer to as a 6-phytase. Here, the IUPAC-IUB recommendations are used
and readers should note that a D-6-phytase and an L-4-phytase produce
the same product.
Myo-inositol is the major nutritionally relevant form of
inositol, and although some of the other stereoisomers also are found in
nature, they will not be addressed in this paper.
Myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5,6) hexakisphosphate has 6 groups of phosphates attached to the inositol ring. Using the prefix “hexakis” instead of “hexa” indicates that the phosphates are not internally connected (Johnson and Tate, 1969)
and the compound is consequently a polydentate ligand, which is a
chelator that can bind to more than one coordination site of the metal
atom. Each of the phosphate groups is esterified to the inositol ring
and together they can bind up to 12 protons in total. The acidity of the
protons varies from very strong acids to very weak (pK
a up to 9.4) although ionic strength of the solution and temperature influence these values (Brown et al., 1961; Costello et al., 1976; Torres et al., 2005).
Trivial names for D-myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5,6) hexakisphosphate are IP6, InsP6 or phytic acid (PA). Thelast two will be used here depending on context and InsP1~InsP5 will also be used regarding lower myo-inositol phosphates counted in D configuration unless the prefix L is explicitly added.
In the pH range 0.5~10.5 phytic acid keeps the sterically stable conformation with one axial and five equatorial groups (Fig.(Fig.2).2).
At higher pH the phytic acid will flip to the reverse conformation with
five axial and one equatorial group. A similar phenomenon is detected
within the InsP5-group, especially the InsP5s with
phosphorylation intact on all three carbon atoms C1, C3 and C5 as these
groups are able to form a “chelation cage” that will use a cation to
stabilise the otherwise more unstable conformation (Volkmann et al., 2002). For the same reason, crystallisation of PA also favors this conformation (He et al., 2006; Rodrigues-Filho et al., 2005). Lower inositol phosphates keep the stabile 5 eq/1 ax conformation over the entire pH range (Barrientos and Murthy, 1996).
Myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5,6) hexakisphosphate in
boat formation showing the 5 equatorial and the 1 axial group. Red
oxygen, purple phosphorous and grey hydrogen atoms form phosphate groups
on each of the blue carbon atoms that have been numbered ...
4.2. Phytate
The chelating effect of the phosphate groups causes PA to bind readily to mineral cations, especially to Cu2+ and Zn2+
which appear to have a high affinity for inositol phosphates. The order
of the ability of the mineral cations to form complexes in vitro with
inositol phosphates has been found to be Cu2+>Zn2+>Cd2+ for all InsP3~InsP6 at pH 3~7, but binding strength is weaker for the lower inositol phosphates (Persson et al., 1998).
Similar binding assays using only phytic acid and none of the lower inositol phosphates show the order Cu2+>Zn2+>Ni2+>Co2+>Mn2+>Fe3+>Ca2+ in one study (Vohra et al., 1965) and the order Zn2+>Cu2+>Co2+>Mn2+>Ca2+ in another (Maddaiah et al., 1964).
Despite of these results, the compositions of minerals in PA stores do
not necessarily follow these orders of affinity.
Recent finding shows
that PA is stored in vivo in complexes not only with these minerals, but
to a much larger extents with Mg, Ca and K (Bohn et al., 2007).
In
presence of excess phytic acid, formation of soluble complexes between
PA and a metal ion displaying 1:1 stoichiometries predominates. However,
when metal ions are in excess, an insoluble solid called phytate is
formed (Torres et al., 2005).
The stoichiometry itself influences the solubility of phytate, as a
very low or a very high metal ion:phytic acid ratio increases the
solubility of the salt (Bullock et al., 1995; Cheryan et al., 1983; Nolan et al., 1987).
However, heterologues precipitation with a combination of more than one
type of metal ions seems to be increasing phytate formation. When
especially Ca2+ is present simultaneously with another metal ion, it increases the proportion of the phytic acid-metal aggregate (Wise and Gilburt, 1983; Simpson and Wise, 1990).
In many cases (Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, Sn and Zn), pure phytic acid-metal salt
precipitates when the stoichiometry between PA and the ion is between
1:2 and 1:5, but addition of chloride ions to the solution can
deprotonise the phytic acid further and form complexes with up to 6 ions
per PA molecule (Vasca et al., 2002; Vohra et al., 1965).
The pH is another factor influencing the solubility of phytic acid (Cheryan, 1980).
Its Ca, Cd, Zn and Cu salts tend to be soluble at pH lower than 4~5,
whereas Mg-phytate is 100% soluble at acid pH up to pH 7.5 (Brown et
al., 1961; Nolan et al., 1987).
Solubility studies of bran phytate prove that at gastric pH
(approximately pH 2), Ca is actually not bound to PA and this component
does not contribute to the solubility of the Ca ion (Siener et al., 2001).
Because the resulting phytate precipitate is amorphous and full of co-crystallised water (up to 22 H2O per PA molecule (Veiga et al., 2006)),
the structure of the phytate salts cannot be obtained by
crystallisation techniques. Attempts to resolve the structure of phytic
acid-Fe3+ salt have revealed quite a high binding capacity
with almost covalent-strong bonds between P-O-Fe. Precipitation
initiates when at least four out of the six phosphate groups, are able
to bind with the Fe3+, leading to iron phytate with 2~4 iron atoms per molecule of PA (Mali et al., 2006).
In the most idealised version of the salt, the ferric ions will be
organised in a grid where each phosphate group is bound to two iron
atoms, and each iron atom is bound to three phosphate groups and shared
between two PA molecules (Thompson and Erdman, 1982).
This is, however, a very constraint structure and in most cases phytic
acid will not be completely saturated with ferric irons.
4.3. Functions of the myo-inositol phosphates
The
primary functions of PA in seeds are storage of phosphates as energy
source and antioxidant for the germinating seed (Raboy, 2003).
Phytate as the mineral bound salt of PA is also an important mineral
reserve in seeds, and it is stored in protein storage vacuoles in the
aleurone cell layer or the embryo of the seed. Lower inositol phosphates
are also involved in stress responses, membrane biogenesis and
intracellular signalling (Storcksdieck et al., 2007; Loewus and Murthy, 2000).
Phytic
acid accumulates during seed development until the seeds reach maturity
and accounts for 60%~90% of total phosphorous content in cereals,
legumes, nuts and oil seeds (Lott et al., 2000; 2001).
It is however found in most eukaryotic tissues, where it is kept
adherent to the cell walls through phosphoinositides, or in complexes
with proteins or ions (Torres et al., 2005; Veiga et al., 2006).
Phytic acid is found in ten-fold higher concentrations in the brains of
rats as in the kidney, indicating that it has great potential outside
the plant kingdom (Grases et al., 2001a).
In eukaryotes in general, three main features of PA keep it involved in a number of metabolic processes: its chelating
properties and its ability to function as a phosphate donor/acceptor
makes it ubiquitous/abundant in numerous cell systems.Moreover, the lower inositol phosphates are involved in a number of cell signalling pathways and finally PA may consequently act as a precursor of compounds with this function.
One of the best known properties
of PA is its antioxidative ability by binding and thereby inactivate Fe
ions in solution. This prevents the ferric irons from participating in
the Fenton reaction (the formation of the hydroxyl radical ·OH as a
consequence of oxidation of Fe2+ to Fe3+ during reaction of Fe2+ with H2O2 or peroxides). PA is even better than the in vitro commonly used EDTA (Graf et al., 1984; Wong and Kitts, 2001).
These radicals are highly reactive molecules that rapidly and
non-specifically react with proteins, lipids or DNA, thereby causing
cell injury or cell death. Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases,
cirrhosis, arthritis and cancer have all been linked with radicals
(Benzie, 2003) and PA may therefore be a potential inhibitor of all of these illnesses.
The
chelating ability of PA is also used in preservation, where historic
ink, made from gallic acid from the tannins and Fe ions, has been used
on paper: phytic acid prevents iron catalysed oxidation of the cellulose
in the paper, thereby doubling the half-life of the documents (Neevel, 1995). InsP5s
with various different combinations of conformations of the phosphate
groups are also capable of inhibiting radical formation, as long as the
1,2,3-(equatorial-axial-equatorial) phosphate conformation is kept
intact (Hawkins et al., 1993), which has also proven useful in paper preservation (Sala et al., 2006).
Quite recently, the ability of PA to inhibit Fe-dependent reactions has
also been tested with some success in storage of meat (Stodolak et al.,
2007).
In mammalian organisms, PA has been implicated in starch digestibility and blood glucose response (Lee et al., 2006), in the prevention of dystropic calcifications in soft tissues (Grases et al., 2004) and kidney stone formation (Grases et al., 1998; Selvam, 2002), and in the lowering of cholesterol and triglycerides (Jariwalla, 1999; Onomi et al., 2004).
PA has also been suggested to be part of a structure that could inhibit
transcription of the viral genome from HIV-1 (Filikov and James, 1998), and apparently it has been tested in toothpaste as a tool for preventing plaque formation (Vasca et al., 2002).
The involvement of phytic acid in cancer therapy is also widely discussed (Vucenik and Shamsuddin, 2006) and the potential of PA in cancer treatment are shown in Table Table2.2.
As with the previously mentioned functions, most of the effects of
phytic acid are related to its chelating abilities, to the lower
inositol’s involvement in signalling pathways or to their phosphate
donor/acceptor capabilities.
After intake, phytic acid is
dephosphorylated to lower inositol phosphates and these can act as an
antioxidant by inhibiting iron mediated oxidative reactions, enhancing
immunity by increasing Natural Killer cell function and activity, or
stimulate bacterial killing by neutrophils. Furthermore, the compounds
can normalise abnormal cell proliferation, induce cell differentiation
and apoptosis and inhibit angiogenesis. In addition, inositol phosphates
modify Phases I and II metabolising enzymes by causing G0/G1 arrest in
cancer cells and modulate oncogene expression and prevent tumor
metastasis formation.
It
should be noted that although many of these functions of lower inositol
phosphates have been shown in vitro, the human small intestines show
very little phytase activity (Iqbal et al., 1994). Even though mammalian cells are able to synthesize the inositol phosphates themselves (York, 2006), endogenous synthesis of phytic acid is minor (Grases et al., 2001a; 2001b).
Using phytic acid in cancer therapy would therefore be dependent on
daily intake of phytic acid. This treatment is influenced by the fact
that absorption rate of PA itself is low (Grases et al., 2006)
and it is suggested that there is a maximum to the uptake in the gut,
which again is regulated by PA plasma levels (Grases et al., 2001c; Kemme et al., 2006).
The effect of phytic acid in cancer therapy is therefore still under
investigation and so far the results have mainly been in connection with
colon cancer, where uptake is not a prerequisite.
Regarding
the negative functions of phytic acid, the outcome of a homogenous and
high PA diet has long been known to be mineral deficiency and
malnutrition (McCance and Widdowson, 1949; Cheryan, 1980).
The negative effects of PA are consequences of the same chemical
features as the potential positive effects. The capability of binding
minerals makes phytic acid an antinutritional factor, because the
solubility of the phytic acid:metal-complexes are low at the pH of the
major part of the intestines. Regarding lower inositol phosphatese, InsP5s
are also able to complex cations, whereas inositol phosphates with only
three or four phosphate groups attached to the inositol ring do not
inhibit mineral absorption independently. They are however able to
interact with PA and thereby contribute to the negative mineral
absorption (Sandberg et al., 1999).
Furthermore, phosphorous in the form of phytic acid is largely
unavailable as a nutritional factor to monogastric animals because
insufficient degradation capabilities in the gastrointestinal tract
prevent the phosphorous from being biologically available. Feeds for
pigs and poultry are therefore traditionally supplemented with inorganic
phosphate to meet the nutritional requirements for optimal growth of
the animals. The excess of phosphorous bond in phytic acid is then
excreted through the faeces and spread as manure into the soil. The
potential eutrophication of fresh water streams, lakes and near costal
areas can then cause cyanobacterial blooms, hypoxia and death of aquatic
animals and production of nitrous oxide, a potential greenhouse gas
(Vats et al., 2005).
In the laboratory, phytic acid in faeces also inhibits polymerase chain
reactions (PCR), thereby preventing PCR-based diagnostic tests for
detecting microorganisms in livestock (Thornton and Passen, 2004).
Chicks fed lpa barley or corn, respectively excrete 33% less phosphate and they show enhanced growth and bone structure (Jang et al., 2003) as compared to chicks on a normal diet. Similar results have been reported for growing pigs (Veum et al., 2002) and rats (Poulsen et al., 2001) on lpa barley diet. Still, almost the same results on growth performance can be achieved by fortifying with inorganic phosphorous instead of using lpa mutants; the main difference between lpa diets and phosphorous fortified diets is therefore the higher phosphorous excretion from the latter.
In human studies, Fe, Ca and Zn uptake increased when meals were based on lpa maize (Adams et al., 2002; Hambidge et al., 2005; Mendoza et al., 1998) and all in all this would be a reasonable approach to increase the bioavailability of micronutrients.
4.4. Storage of phytic acid
Phytic acid and its co-precipitated cations are stored in electron dense spherical particles named globoids (Pfeffer, 1872). The globoids are localised predominantly in the aleurone layer (wheat and barley) or in the embryo (maize) (Odell et al., 1972).
They are compartmentalised inside protein storage vacuoles in the
seeds. Protein storage vacuoles in general contain three morphologically
distinct regions: a matrix that contains most of the soluble storage
proteins, crystalloids composed of proteins yet to be investigated but
organised in lattice structure, and globoids of PA or oxalate crystals
(Lott, 1980).
How many of these regions are present in the seed is species dependent.
Protein storage vacuoles of wheat are composed only of matrix proteins
and phytate globoids (Morrison et al., 1975)
which make the cells highly susceptible to extraction of phytate.
Consequently, even a minor rupture of the aleurone cells means release
of phytate into the surrounding environment (Antoine et al., 2004). Morrison et al.(1975)
also reported the detection of a layer of lipid droplets around the
wheat “aleurone grain”. Membranes surrounding the globoids have been
reported in other species such as Brassicaceae (Gillespie et al., 2005) and Solanaceae (tomato) (Jiang et al., 2001). Certain reports of the phenomenon in wheat has however not been published to date, but the findings of Morrison et al.(1975)
could be parts of an inner membrane in the protein storage vacuole,
which have been broken during staining and cutting of the samples.
The
size of the phytate globoids depends on the amount of phytate in the
grain. In wildtype (WT) wheat, globoids up to 4 μm in diameter have been
detected (Antoine et al., 2004),
whereas a low phytic acid (lpa) wheat mutant (Js-12-LPA) with the same
amount of P in the grains but lowered phytate concentration has smaller
globoids, organised in clusters (Joyce et al., 2005). This phenomenon has also been observed in WT wheat grown under low P conditions (Batten and Lott, 1986) and in lpa mutations in other cereals, such as rice (Liu et al., 2004), maize (Lin et al., 2005) and barley (Ockenden et al.,2004)
The
compositions of the globoids seem to be the same for globoids from WT
and lpa wheat. Using scanning transmission electron
microscopy-energy-dispersive X-ray analyses on section of wheat grains,
P, K, Mg and Ca are found in high concentration in globoids (Joyce et
al., 2005), whereas especially Cu and Zn are lowered in lpa compared to WT (Guttieri et al., 2003).
Minerals were recently quantified by inductively coupled plasma-mass
spectrometry (ICP-MS) of phytate globoids purified from wheat bran (Bohn
et al., 2007).
Although Cu has high affinity to phytic acid, there is no indication
that Cu-phytate globoids are the primary storage facility for this
element and K;Mg;Ca;Fe (in concentration order) were found as
the main minerals (Bohn et al., 2007).
Fe is also found in both lpa and WT wheat, but its distribution is
restricted because globoids near the embryo were shown to contain the
relatively highest amounts of this element in WT wheat (Lott and
Spitzer, 1980).
Dephytinisation and nutrition
The
chelating properties of PA not only result in the binding of cations in
seeds. When released during food or feed processing or in the gut, PA
also binds minerals and makes them unavailable as nutritional factors.
Iron and zinc uptake have both been shown to be inhibited when the
phytic acid:metal ratio increases above 10:1 (Gharib et al., 2006; Glahn et al., 2002).
In human studies, phytic acid has been reported to inhibit absorption
of iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium and manganese but surprisingly not
copper (Bohn et al., 2004; Davidsson et al., 1995; Egli et al., 2004; Hallberg et al., 1989; Lonnerdal, 1997; Phillippy, 2006; Reddy et al., 1996).
Removal or degradation of PA would therefore increase the
bioavailability of many cations and the nutritional value of the meal,
and several strategies to reduce it are therefore considered.
Milling
of cereals removes the phytic acid, but this treatment also removes the
major parts of the minerals and dietary fibres and cannot therefore be a
nutritional solution to the problem. Similarly, soaking or extracting
in aqueous solutions can remove up to two thirds of the PA by the action
of endogenous phytase activity, but loss of minerals, water-extractable
proteins and vitamins also occurs (Hurrell, 2004). Heat treatments have minor effects (Pontoppidan et al., 2007)
usually due to leaching of minerals into the boiling water. Different
processing and cooking methodologies for reduction of PA have been
compared between wheat variety, and the results have been that if one
method is efficient in reduction of PA in one wheat variety, this may
not apply for another. Furthermore, the method with the highest phytic
acid reduction (germination for 48 h) still only reduced its content by
up to 40% (Masud et al., 2007).
Avoiding PA formation in the first place or catalysing its degradation
by the use of PA hydrolysing enzymes would therefore be more beneficial
approaches to dephytinisation.
Reducing phytate content through lpa mutants have been attempted through knock-out of genes involved in PA biosynthesis.
With the only exception of one barley mutant accumulating Fe, the
mineral composition does not dramatically change in lpa mutants,
indicating that there is no direct link between mineral distribution and
phytic acid biosynthesis (Joyce et al., 2005; Liu J.C. et al., 2004; Liu K. et al., 2007; Ockenden et al., 2004).Chicks fed lpa barley or corn, respectively excrete 33% less phosphate and they show enhanced growth and bone structure (Jang et al., 2003) as compared to chicks on a normal diet. Similar results have been reported for growing pigs (Veum et al., 2002) and rats (Poulsen et al., 2001) on lpa barley diet. Still, almost the same results on growth performance can be achieved by fortifying with inorganic phosphorous instead of using lpa mutants; the main difference between lpa diets and phosphorous fortified diets is therefore the higher phosphorous excretion from the latter.
In human studies, Fe, Ca and Zn uptake increased when meals were based on lpa maize (Adams et al., 2002; Hambidge et al., 2005; Mendoza et al., 1998) and all in all this would be a reasonable approach to increase the bioavailability of micronutrients.
Due
to the involvement of the lower inositol phosphates in plant cell
metabolism, production of the perfect lpa mutant has however turned out
to be quite a challenge. Since many kinases and tranferases are involved
in the synthesis of phytic acid (Josefsen et al., 2007),
the mutants often find ways to circumvent the knocked out pathway.
Furthermore, the yield or germination ability is affected if PA content
is reduced more than 50% (Raboy, 2007),
thereby making this approach unattractive from an economic perspective.
The best result so far is the maize lpa1 mutant, which is mutated in an
embryo-specific ATP-binding cassette (ABC)-transporter and it is able to
hold up to 90% reduction of PA without compromising seed viability. The
effect on mineral distribution in this mutant is yet to be evaluated
(Shi et al., 2007).
Instead of blocking its biosynthesis, an attempt to reduce PA in wheat products has been performed by introducing the Aspergillus niger phytase gene phyA into a wheat variety by particle bombardments of immature wheat embryos (Holm et al., 2002). The concerted action of wheat phytase and Aspergillus
phytase has proven to be an efficient way of increasing the rate of PA
degradation in transgenic wheat flour, although experiments in food or
feed applications have not been reported yet.
The
most successful dephytinisations so far involve endogenous enzymatic
activity during germination, but this is a species dependent phenomenon
where some plants are more sensitive to the treatment than others.
Wheat, barley and rye all have high phytase activity in the grain,
whereas maize, millet and sorghum have low initial phytase activity that
increase rapidly after germination (Egli et al., 2002).
Adding exogenous phytase to food and feed is therefore under
investigation in many forms and the next section will present the
general classes of phytases and some of the applications.
5. PHYTASES
5.1. Definition
The term phytase (myo-inositol (1,2,3,4,5,6) hexakisphosphate
phosphohydrolase) is defined as a class of phosphatases with the in
vitro capability to release at least one phosphate from PA, thereby
releasing phosphate and lowering inositol phosphates and potentially
chelated minerals.
The earliest reports of a phytase activity are from the blood of calves (McCollum and Hart, 1908), and rice bran (Suzuki et al., 1907),
indicating from its discovery, that this enzyme is found in diverse
organisms. Later discoveries have also found phytases in bacteria, yeast
and fungi. As previously mentioned, most monogastric animals, including
humans, lack the enzyme in their digestive track, making PA hydrolysis
in the gut dependent on mucosal or bacterial enzymes or on non-enzymatic
hydrolysis by gastrointestinal acidity. The number of enzymes described
as phytases has increased rapidly over the years and details regarding
the enzymatic properties can be found in several reviews (Haefner et
al., 2005; Oh et al., 2004; Vats and Banerjee, 2004).
IUPAC-IUBMB
(the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry and the
International Union of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology) currently
acknowledges three classes of phytase enzymes, which initiate the
dephosphorylation of PA at different positions on the inositol ring, and
produce different isomers of the lower inositol phosphates. Within each
class of phytase structural differences can be found, and not all
enzymes within a certain class hydrolyze phosphate from PA through the
same mechanism. Similarly, the enzymes can be grouped as acidic, neutral
or alkaline phosphatases depending on the optimum pH of activity. All
phytases however have pronounced stereo specificity and a strong
preference for equatorial phosphate groups over axial groups (Lei and
Porres, 2003).
5.2. EC 3.1.3.8: the 3-phytases
The
largest group of phytases to date contains the 3-phytases (EC 3.1.3.8),
which in general are found in fungi and bacteria. Structurally, most of
the 3-phytases show homology to β-propeller phosphatase (BPP), or
histidine acid phosphatases (HAP).
BPPs are tightly
bound to three Ca ions and need two adjacent phosphate groups to bind to
the “cleavage site” and to the “affinity site” before hydrolysis can
occur. The end product has been suggested to be
inositol-triphosphate—either Ins(1,3,5)P3 or Ins(2,4, 6)P3 (Kerovuo et al., 2000; Shin et al., 2001), but most recent data give evidence that Ins(2,4,6)P3 is sole the end product (Oh et al., 2006), confirming the equatorial preference of most phytases.
Most
bacterial, fungal and plant phytases belong to the HAPs. Within this
structural classification, there are two phytase subgroups: Some show
broad substrate specificity but low specific activity for PA, whereas
others have narrow substrate specificities but high specific activity
for PA All members of the HAP class share two conserved active site motifs, RHGXRXP and HD (van Etten et al., 1991),
and hydrolyse metal-free phytate in the acidic pH-range. However, they
do not necessarily share any additional regions of sequence similarity
(Maugenest et al., 1997). HAPs can initiate hydrolysis of phytic acid on either the C3 or the C6 position of the inositol ring and produce myo-inositol monophosphate (in particular Ins(2)P due to its axial position) as the final product (Greiner and Carlsson, 2006; Mullaney and Ullah, 2003; Oh et al., 2006).
Some similar properties are displayed by the investigated wheat phytases (Table (Table3).3).
All the enzymes characterised so far have been most active at weak
acidic to neutral pH. Optimum activity lies between pH 4.5 and 7.2 and
there are several reports of an enzyme with the highest activity around
pH 6. This suggests that they all are acid phosphatases. Temperature optimum is in the range of 45 °C (Bohn et al., 2007; Nakano et al., 1999) to 65 °C (Dionisio et al., 2007)
and there is general agreement concerning inhibition by approximately 3
mmol/L phosphate of some types of phytases but not others.
Inconsistencies in the characterisations primarily regard the activities
of the enzymes. The K
m vary between 0.48 μmol/L and 830 μmol/L phytic acid and the velocities at maximal concentrations of substrates (V
max) vary from 127 to 230 μmol Pi/(mg·min) (Bohn et al., 2007; Nakano et al., 1999).
Anderson and Wolf (1995) published a review on the changes in phytate concentration related to the processing of soy beans, and the most recent research showed that soy flour is the type of soy-bean product containing the highest amount of phytate (Al-Wahsh et al., 2005).
The
catalytic mechanism of hydrolysis by HAPs is proposed to be as follows:
the histidine residue in the conserved motif is used to make a
nucleophilic attack on the carbon of interest, and an aspartic acid in
the C-terminal of the enzyme stabilizes the leaving group by acting as a
proton donor (Ostanin and van Etten, 1993; Ostanin et al., 1992).
A water molecule is consumed in the hydrolysis of the intermediate, but
the phospho-histidine interaction is stable enough for crystallization,
as it has been done e.g., with a heat stable HAP phytase from Aspergillus fumigatus (Xiang et al., 2004).
A well studied phytase from the class of 3-phytases is isolated from baker’s yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This phytase is extracellular and its expression of it can be induced when grown in a medium containing InsP6 as the sole phosphorous source (Andlid et al., 2004). The extracellular yeast 3-phytase has been studied intensively as its potential during baking is obvious (Turk et al., 1996).
Unfortunately, the endogenous phytase of yeast is repressed by the
concentrations of phosphate in the dough during leavening (Andlid et
al., 2004). Constitutive expression of yeast phytase is possible by deletion of genes expressing negative regulators (Veide and Andlid, 2006),
but recent investigations have to a large extent advanced to focusing
on the use of baker’s yeast as host for heterologues expression of
microbial phytases due to their higher thermostability (Kaur et al., 2007).
The sequential dephosphorylation of phytic acid by an S. cerevisiae phytase is depicted in Fig.Fig.3.3. Not all subproducts have been confirmed yet, but the major pathway is from phytic acid over Ins(1,2,4,5,6)P5 through Ins(1,2,5,6)P4 and Ins(1,2,6)P3 to probably Ins(1,2)P2. End product is Ins(2)P (Andlid et al., 2004; Greiner and Alminger, 2001).
Dephosphorylation of phytic acid by the 3-phytase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae.
Hydrolysis of phytic acid initiates on C3 of the inositol ring and the
adjacent phosphates are removed consecutively. Fat arrows indicate major
pathway of dephosphorylation, ...
5.3. EC 3.1.3.72: the 5-phytase
Only a single 5-phytase (EC 3.1.3.72) has been detected so far. This alkaline phytase from lily pollen is interesting, because it is the only one in the family of phytases that initiates hydrolysis with an attack of a phosphate group in the plane of symmetry (the “turtle’s tail”), thereby creating yet another symmetrical compound as shown in Fig.Fig.44 (Barrientos et al., 1994).
The pollen phytase shows highest activity at pH 8.0 and temperature 55 °C (Jog et al., 2005).
It has the conformation of an HAP phytase, but with the exception of
the active site, the amino acid sequence homology is higher towards
multiple inositol polyphosphate phosphatase (MINPP) from humans or rats
(Mehta et al., 2006).
5.4. EC 3.1.3.26: the 4/6-phytases
The
4/6-phytases (EC 3.1.3.26) act on the carbon atom next to C5 of the
inositol ring. The official name should be 4-phytase, but traditionally
it has been called a 6-phytase. Several structurally different phytases
are found in this group: The purple acid phosphatase (PAP), the ADP
phosphoglycerate phosphatase (related to EC 3.1.3.28), as previously
mentioned an HAP-class is also involved, and again the acid phosphatase
(related to EC 3.1.3.2).
Plant phytases act
preferentially at the C6 carbon, and are 6-phytases. In general, the
4/6-phytases are the most active in weak acidic environments (pH 4~6)
with a temperature optimum in the range 40~60 °C. They are usually 50~70
kD and have Michaelis-Menten constants (K
m) in the range of 10−5~10−4 mol/L phytic acid. There are exceptions, such as the rather large phytase from tomato roots (164 kD (Li et al., 2007)) and the highly active phytase from wheat (K
m 0.5 μmol/L phytic acid (Nakano et al., 1999)).
Also, some alkaline phytases have been purified, such as the previously
mentioned 5-phytase from lily pollen, legume seeds and the phytase from
Typha latifolia (cattail) pollen (Hara et al., 1985; Jog et al., 2005; Scott, 1991). Their pH optima lie at pH 8. A list of characterised plant phytases are found in Table Table33.
Phytases
purified from plants and their properties. The lower part of the table
describes the properties of cereal phytases; the top part of the table
shows examples of other plant phytases in alphabetical order. If more
than one phytase is referred to, ...
5.5. Wheat phytase
Activity of wheat phytases (EC 3.1.3.26) were first reported in (Posternak and Posternak, 1929), where an aqueous extract of wheat bran was used to investigate optically active myo-inositol polyphosphate esters that were produced during the degradation of phytate. Attempts to characterise the enzymes were performed by Collatz and Bailey (1921), and Kolobkowa (1936). Both groups found 55 °C to be the optimum temperature for wheat phytase, as a result that was confirmed along with optimum pH of 5.15 (Peers, 1953). Despite these fairly similar results it should however be noted that none of the groups managed to purify the enzymes to homogeneity and that it required additionally 20 years before a pure phytase from wheat was identified.
The number of phytases in wheat is still
under investigation. Two enzymes, Phy1 and Phy2, have previously been
purified from wheat bran (Lim and Tate, 1973) and two isozymes with the N-terminal amino acid sequence EPAXTLTGPSRPV have also been purified (Nakano et al., 1999).
Based on amino acid sequence and masses of tryptic peptides, a third
enzyme with homology to PAP phytases was cDNA cloned from wheat and its
homologue from barley (Rasmussen et al., 2007).
Recently four cDNAs encoding for MINPPs were also cloned. At least two
of these show in vitro phytase activity and they are probably expressed
during late seed development and germination (Dionisio et al., 2007).
Although a PAP phytase has also been found in soybean (Hegeman and Grabau, 2001),
wheat phytase is mainly used as model for characterisation of this type
of phytase. It has been documented to be inhibited when the phytate is
complexed with Al3+, Cu2+, Fe2+, Fe3+, Ag+, Hg+ or Zn2+, but not salts of Ca2+, Mg2+ and Mn2+
unless some of the inhibiting ions are present in the solution as well.
Organic acids, such as citric acid or oxalate, can to a certain extent
circumvent this inhibition, but in too high doses they themselves become
inhibitory factors (Nagai and Funahashi, 1962; Tang et al., 2006).
The exact structure of PAP phytase has not been elucidated yet, but PAPs usually contain a Fe3+-Me2+ centre in their active site, where Me stands for divalent Fe, Mn or Zn (Olczak et al., 2003; Strater et al., 1995). Five conserved regions containing seven negatively charged amino acids stabilise this structure (Fig.(Fig.5).5).
The PAPs catalyse the hydrolysis of activated phosphoric acid esters
and anhydrides in the pH range from 4 to 7 (Vincent et al., 1992) through an interaction between the Me2+ and the substrate followed by a nucleophilic attack on the phosphate group by a Fe3+-coordinated hydroxide ion (Klabunde et al., 1996). Three histidines in the conserved regions stabilise the transition state.
Alignment of wheat phytase to related PAPs in other plants: Orysa sativa, Medicago truncatula and Glycine max.
The five conserved regions (black boxes) contain the seven invariant
amino acids (bold) involved in coordination of the metals in the
binuclear ...
The sequential dephosphorylation of PA by wheat phytase has been studied by several groups (Bohn et al., 2007; Lim and Tate, 1973; Nakano et al., 2000; Tomlinson and Ballou, 1962), and it has been determined that it acts through both C6 and C3 to yield myo-inositol (Fig.(Fig.6).6).
This is also the case when isolated phytate globoids are used as the
substrate, although the activity of the wheat phytase decreases
approximately 30% on globoids as compared to when acting on pure PA
(Bohn et al., 2007).
6. PHYTASE IN APPLICATIONS
Degradation
of PA and the release of phosphorous and minerals have as previously
described been of great interest to human and animal nutritionists as
well as ecologists. The development of the most optimal method for
applying phytase into food and feed is an on-going process with multiple
pathways. The first commercially available phytase was from Aspergillus niger (NatuphosTM, BASF) in 1991, but now several phytases are on the market, from e.g., Peniophora lycii (RonozymeTM, DSM/Novozymes), Escherichia coli (QuantumTM, Diversa/Syngenta) and Schizosaccharomyces pombe
(PhyzymeTM, Diversa/Danisco). The major problem in production of plant
phytases is that a cost-effective and efficient production of the
enzymes is yet to be developed. The higher pH and thermal stability of
microbial phytases compared to plant phytases have made the microbial
phytases more investigated for industrial purposes.
6.1. Production of phytase in transgenic plants
The first hurdle in the use of phytase as means for decreasing PA concentration is the production of phytase. In planta production of phytases can be used to reduce the amount of PA in feed for animals, but one of the problems in this regard is the stability of the enzyme. In wheat and barley the WT Aspergillus fumigatus phytase has been expressed (Brinch-Pedersen et al., 2003) as well as a heat stable engineered phytase. Although the native Aspergillus phytase had high regeneration abilities after heat treatment, it was found that high temperature stability was a more reliable approach to generating low phytic acid feed (Brinch-Pedersen et al., 2006).
In
several experiments it has been confirmed that “biofarming” of the
phytase is a cost-effective approach to its production. Native Aspergillus ficuum
phytase has been expressed in tobacco, alfalfa and potato leaves. The
most common approach is to use the Cauliflower Mosaic Virus (CaMV) 35S
promoter for the construct, and the results are enzymes with almost the
same characteristics as the fungal phytase, although minor changes in pH
optima and sizes have been observed (Ullah et al., 1999; 2002; 2003). Similar experiments with a heat stable A. fumigatus phytase expressed in tobacco leaves and Pichia pastoris have also shown great potential. Especially regarding feed production, the relatively high heat resistance of the A. fumigatus
enzyme is an important asset because the enzyme will then be able to
withstand the elevated temperatures employed during feed pelleting
processes (Wang et al., 2007).
Purification of the phytase is not always necessary for applications: a transgenic strain of Bacillus mucilaginosus,
a rhizosphere soil organism able to express high phytase activity
extracellularly and degrade PA in the soil, has proven to be able to
promote tobacco growth and increase phosphorous content in the plant,
thereby potentially limiting eutrophication (Li et al., 2007).
Of more nutritional relevance are experiments performed on pigs that
were fed fresh rice leaves expressing yeast phytase. The leaves were
ground and mixed with a grain-based diet, and PA was degraded using up
to twelve weeks old leaves, indicating that the yeast phytase is quite
resistant to denaturation when expressed in rice (Hamada et al., 2006).
6.2. Phytase as feed additive
Exogenous phytase in feed has multiple benefits, mainly in increasing mineral, phosphorous and energy uptake and thereby decreasing the necessity to fortify the fodder with these substances. The increased availability of phytic acid phosphorous at the same time decreases phosphorous excretion and hence reducing the phosphate load in water supplies in regions with intensive rearing of animals. Comparison of 4 commercially available phytases as fortifiers of pigs feed revealed that none of them satisfied all of the criteria of an ideal phytase for feed production, such as resistance to denaturation under extreme temperatures and pH (Boyce and Walsh, 2006). Nonetheless, supplemental microbial phytase increased P availability by 38%, 12% and 15% in pig diets containing maize, wheat and triticale, respectively (Dungelhoef et al., 1994), and up to 60% reduction in manure P due to phytase supplementation has been reported (Nahm, 2002). Experiments with growing pigs have also shown that the Zn supply can be reduced to approximately 1/3 of the otherwise required amount in a diet based on maize and soybean when microbial phytase is added (Revy et al., 2006). Furthermore, average daily energy intake from feed actually increases with the addition of phytase, making it necessary to reduce the amount of feed offered to the pigs in order to prevent them from producing too much fat in the muscle tissue (Brady et al., 2003; Revy et al., 2006).
In
broiler chickens, supplementing with exogenous phytase has reduced the
excretion of endogenous amino acids, calcium, sodium, phytate phosphorus
and sialic acid significantly (Cowieson et al., 2004; Nahm, 2002).
As in pigs, increased weight gain from a phytase supplemented diet is
also reported for broilers. It has been predicted that in both cases
this response will be declining with time, due to improvements in animal
strains, feeds and management techniques (Selle and Ravindran, 2007).
Exchanging
a meat based protein-rich diet with a lower cost plant protein diet
would be desired by the industry of aquaculture. However, fish in
general have rather short gastrointestinal tracts, and are therefore
quite sensitive to the inhibited micronutrient utilisation.
Dephytinisation of the plant material is consequently an important
prerequisite to this application. The effects on phosphate utilization
and growth of fish using phytase treated fodder are to date inconsistent
and species-related. Some fish have a basic environment (pH 8) in the
gastrointestinal tract which does not correspond to the conditions for
optimal phytase activity, and although the potential in dephytinisation
is there, for once the acidic microbial phytases may not be the first
choice of enzyme (Cao et al., 2007).
Another
approach to the degradation of PA by monogastric animals is to create
transgenic livestock. A transgenic pig that constitutively secretes
microbial phytase from their salivary glands has been generated and it
shows up to 75% reduction in phosphorous excretion (Golovan et al., 2001a; 2001b).
Furthermore, its requirements for inorganic phosphorous supplementation
are decreased to almost zero. Similarly, another group has experimented
with expressing an avian MINPP phytase in chickens. This approach would
overcome public skepticism towards “foreign” proteins in the food
(Ward, 2001) and still decrease phosphorous demands of the transgenic line (Cho et al., 2006).
6.3. Phytase as food additive
Degradation of PA during breadmaking has been known to effect mineral bioavailability for many years (Mollgaard, 1946).
Several breadmaking procedures designed to diminish the phytate content
have therefore been reported. These include the addition of commercial
phosphoesterases from wheat (phytase or phosphatase) to whole wheat
flour (Knorr et al., 1981) and the activation of the naturally occurring phytase by soaking and malting the grain.
Phytase
shows potential as a breadmaking improver, with two main advantages:
first, the nutritional improvement produced by decreasing phytate
content, and second, all the benefits produced by α-amylase addition (increase in bread
volume and improvement in crumb texture) can be obtained by adding
phytase, which releases calcium and thereby promotes the activation of
endogenous α-amylase (Haros et al., 2001a).
The changes in pH values during leavening of bread have been measured
to approximately 0.2 pH-units. The pH values ranged between 6.3 and 6.1
in yeast-doughs (Leenhardt et al., 2005) and 5.6 and 5.4 in sourdoughs (Haros et al., 2001b). Wheat phytase has an optimal pH of 6.0 (Bohn et al., 2007), and its activity diminishes markedly as the pH is moved more than 0.5 pH-units from optimum. Conversely, Aspergillus niger phytase has two pH optima, one at 5.0 and the other at 2.5~3.0 (Turk and Sandberg, 1992). Therefore, as the pH decreases along the leavening, higher phytase activity is observed using the Aspergillus phytase (Haros et al., 2001b).
Enhancing the degradation by using an organic acid such as citric acid
to acidify the dough is a possibility, although leavening for at least 2
h is required for maximal phytate hydrolysis by phytase (Porres et al.,
2001).
Consequently, degradation of PA in sourdoughs with long leavening
times, such as rye bread, is preferable, and its degradation is almost
completed by endogenous phytase in this type of bread, leaving InsP3 as the dominating inositol phosphate (Nielsen et al., 2007). Unless they are able to complex with higher inositol phosphates, InsP3s do not inhibit iron uptake in humans (Brune et al., 1992; Sandberg et al., 1999) and the rye bread should therefore contain bioavailable iron for consumption.
However,
although the non-heme iron absorption in humans almost doubles from
wheat bread rolls treated with fungal phytase compared to bread
untreated with phytase (Sandberg et al., 1996),
one should be aware that a minor reduction of phytic acid is not enough
to maintain iron status in the long run. Whole grain bread, where
dephytinisation is not completed even after long leavening (Nielsen et
al., 2007), should therefore not be consumed to all main meals (Bach Kristensen et al., 2005) to avoid constant mineral uptake inhibition.
Iron
absorption from porridges based on flours from rice, wheat, maize, oat,
sorghum and wheat-soy flour blend have been tested on humans. The
results show that phytate degradation improves iron absorption from
cereal porridges prepared with water but not with milk, and that
addition of ascorbic acid actually is a better tool for enhancing iron
absorption in baby food than addition of phytase. Adding amylase to the
porridge in combination with phytase makes the solution more liquid, and
probably because of this, the absorption of Fe increases another 3-fold
(Hurrell et al., 2003).
Interestingly
enough, phytate in tofu is actually considered a positive feature,
since phytate inhibits chrystal formation of calcium oxalate—also known
as kidney stones. In general, oxalate-rich soy foods also contain higher
concentrations of phytate, but most commercially available tofu is
categorised as low oxalate/phytate food.Anderson and Wolf (1995) published a review on the changes in phytate concentration related to the processing of soy beans, and the most recent research showed that soy flour is the type of soy-bean product containing the highest amount of phytate (Al-Wahsh et al., 2005).
In
summary, phytases have potential for improving mineral bioavailability
in food applications. Due to the higher stability of fungal phytases,
these would probably be the most efficient in degradation of phytic
acid, and the activity of e.g., Aspergillus niger would even be
increased in the acidic environment in the stomach. One should however
note that in bread applications with long leavening time, exogenous
phytase is not necessarily required for phytate degradation, unless
whole grains are added to the mixture.
Footnotes
*Project supported by the Danish Agency for Science, Technology and Innovation, Copenhagen, Denmark and HarvestPlus
Article information
J Zhejiang Univ Sci B. Mar 2008; 9(3): 165–191.
PMCID: PMC2266880
Received February 5, 2008; Accepted February 18, 2008.
Copyright © 2008, Journal of Zhejiang University Science
This article has been cited by other articles in PMC.
Articles from Journal of Zhejiang University. Science. B are provided here courtesy of Zhejiang University Press
Inga kommentarer:
Skicka en kommentar